Before Litchfield Edit
Bennett is revealed to have been a corporal in the United States Army prior to working at Litchfield. He was on a tour of duty in Afghanistan. He tosses a bottle of water to an Afghan attache. He asks the attache why his three partners look nauseated and upset, and is informed that the other three Afghan attachés believe all the soldiers at the camp are "boy kissy boy" (homosexual) after seeing the soldiers engaging in choreographed song and dance while filming a homoerotic parody video. Bennett unwittingly confirms that he can see how they think the soldiers are gay.
While remotely viewing an air strike, the soldiers are shown to be eating ice cream while Bennett talks about the lack of combat on his tour. The three Afghan men are seen pushing and arguing with the new friend. He breaks loose from their group and attempts to warn the soldiers that his fellow three are going to attack and bomb the tent, and is shot and killed. The other three run while one throws a fragmenting grenade in the tent. Bennett is told to kick it away, but he instead dives for cover as a fellow soldier shrouds the grenade with his body in a heroic act to save the other soldiers ("Bed Bugs and Beyond").
Some time before working at Litchfield, Bennett had his left leg amputated after obtaining an infection at a hot tub in Orlando. He wears a prosthetic leg.
Bennett is among the many correctional officers that check Piper Chapman into the prison. He is new to Litchfield. Bennett begins flirting with Dayanara Diaz, who arrives to prison the same day Piper does ("I Wasn't Ready").
Bennett and Daya quickly begin a romantic relationship. Daya discovers his artificial leg while she was performing oral sex on him in a utility closet. At one point, Daya's mother Aleida attempts to seduce him, which he rebuffs. He confides to Daya that he is under a lot of pressure to be tougher on the girls, and fakes reprimanding her in front of the other prisoners and staff.
Daya discovers that she is pregnant with Bennett's baby. Aleida, Gloria and Red come up with an idea to explain the pregnancy: Daya will have sex with George "Pornstache" Mendez and say that the baby is his (this would also get him fired for rape in the process). Bennett is unhappy about Daya having sex with Pornstache, but she assures him it is for the good of their baby. The plan is successful, and Mendez is put on temporary leave from Litchfield.
The stress of having a baby with a prisoner begins to weigh on Bennett. Mendez returns to Litchfield after his suspension, and Bennett is outraged. He uncharacteristically takes out his rage on Vee's gang, tearing apart their living space while conducting a search. He then sends Maritza Ramos to the SHU when she tries to blackmail him. He attempts to have a normal relationship with Daya, who often rejects his advances due to his aggresive attitude (towards the other inmates). The two still share a number of sweet and romantic moments together despite the situation.
In an attempt to rid Mendez permanently from Litchfield, he confesses to Caputo about Daya's pregnancy without her permission, saying that Mendez is the father. Caputo fires Mendez and also has him arrested for rape. Eventually, under pressure from Daya, he confesses to being the father of her child to Caputo. This angers Caputo, who was just previously promoted. Caputo commands Bennett to keep this a secret ("We Have Manners. We're Polite").
He proposes to Daya by giving her a ring made out of gum wrappers. However, he later flees after visiting her family, and witnessing the life his child would have with Cesar and Daya's siblings when Cesar threatens one of his stepchildren with a gun. As Bennett is about to leave, Cesar gives him the crib that belonged to Daya as a baby. He later leaves it by the side of the road and runs away ("Bed Bugs and Beyond").
Daya had intended to give their baby to Delia Powell, George Mendez's mother. At the last minute, however, Aleida calls her and tells her that the baby boy died after the umbilical cord wrapped around his neck. In reality, Daya had given birth to a daughter who is given to Cesar upon her release from the hospital ("Don't Make Me Come Back There").
John Bennett is one of the kinder guards within the prison. He is liked by the inmates even though at times he may come off as being crazy such as the moments where he threatened Daya's kitchen-mates in order to keep the secret that he is the biological father of Daya's daughter from coming out. However, out of all the inmates he shows a huge amount of kindness and respect towards Daya even when she first arrived at the prison. He carries himself as straight-laced, almost like a Boy Scout, but at times has a military bearing.
Physical Appearance Edit
John Bennett has short dark-brown hair and is mostly seen in his correctional officer uniform in the episodes. However, at home, he is seen wearing more casual attire, such as when he came to Cesar's house to inform him of Daya's pregnancy. He has a prosthetic left leg, which is originally thought to be from his tour in Afghanistan, but is later revealed to be the result of an infection from a dirty hot tub in Orlando, Florida.
- "You got a little, uh, between your two teeth."
- — John Bennett
- "It'd look funny, like I liked you."
- — John Bennett
- "I got laid."
- — John Bennett
- "I'm not buying gay porn."
- — John Bennett
- Listens to Fleet Foxes
- Trying to quit smoking by chewing tobacco instead.